IN LOVING MEMORY OF

Mary Kay

(Knisley) Cain

April 19, 1957 – July 2, 2025

Obituary

CAIN

Mary Kay Cain, age 68, of London, died Wednesday, July 2, 2025, in her residence. Born April 19, 1957, in London, Kay was the beloved daughter of Donald Knisley Sr. and Patricia (Burt) Knisley.

Kay thoroughly enjoyed perusing yard sales in search of her next great find, and she also enjoyed anything and everything related to Elvis Presley. Although she would walk a mile for a good yard sale, her absolute favorite pastime was always spending time with her grandchildren and great-granddaughter, for they were the true lights of her life. The countless memories they made together are irreplaceable and will be forever cherished as her legacy continues through them.

Survivors include her sons: Ricky (Jen) Cain Jr. and Josh (Marcia) Cain; son-in-law William Moore II; grandchildren Logan Cain, Josh Cain Jr., and Braelon Cain; great-granddaughter Rosaline Castillo; brother Donald Knisley Jr.; numerous nieces, nephews, and other relatives.

Kay was preceded in death by her parents and adored daughter Patty Cain.

A time of gathering will be held on Sunday, July 13, 2025, from 4:00 – 6:00 PM in the EBERLE-FISHER FUNERAL HOME AND CREMATORY, 103 North Main Street, London, Ohio 43140, with a Celebration of Kay's Life beginning at 6:00 PM in which friends are invited to bring their favorite memories of Kay to share.

In lieu of flowers, memorials in Kay's name may be sent to the funeral home for the benevolence of the family to offset funeral expenses. Memorials may be submitted online through the "Donations" tab at the top of the obituary, or by contacting the funeral home directly.

Condolences for the Cain family are encouraged to be shared online at www.eberlefisherfuneralhome.com.

To order memorial trees or send flowers to the family in memory of Mary Kay (Knisley) Cain, please visit our flower store.
provider thumbnail

Services

Memorial Visitation

Calendar
July
13

Eberle-Fisher Funeral Home

103 N Main St, London, OH 43140

4:00 - 6:00 pm

Celebration of Life

Calendar
July
13

Eberle-Fisher Funeral Home

103 N Main St, London, OH 43140

Starts at 6:00 pm

Mary Kay (Knisley) Cain's Guestbook

Visits: 0

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors